Arroyo (9-3) picked up his fourth win in his last five decisions. He gave up just two runs as the Reds ended a three-game slide and won for just the second time in their last 10 games.
Ken Griffey Jr. had a sixth-inning homer and Brandon Phillips added a pair of insurance runs in the eighth for Cincinnati. Griffey's homer was the 548th in his career, moving him into a tie for 11th all-time with Hall-of-Famer Mike Schmidt.
Carlos Beltran homered and drove in two runs for New York, which has lost three of its last four games.
New York starter Orlando Hernandez (4-6) suffered the loss, despite yielding just two runs on eight hits in seven innings.
NBC reportedly holds celebs hostage to Jimmy Fallon's show
Millions of Getty images now available for free via embed tool