Defenseman Dan Boyle had three assists for the Lightning (4
Playing without its best player, Tampa Bay scored on three of its eight power plays against the undisciplined Rangers, who were booed off home ice after extending their winless streak to three games (0-1-2).
Lightning center Vincent Lecavalier, the first overall pick in the 1998 draft, sat out with a knee injury.
New York had a 2-1 lead following Mark Messier's power-play goal 3:28 into the second period but was whistled for five minor penalties over the next 16 minutes.
The Lightning scored on two of the ensuing power plays, eventually chasing backup goaltender Dan Blackburn. St. Louis tied it at 2-2 with his first goal of the night at 7:39, and Vaclav Prospal made it 3-2 at 14:56.