Police said the figures were taken from the Quincy Center Nativity scene at some point prior to 1 a.m. Thursday, Boston.com reported Thursday.
Capt. John Dougan said the Jesus statue had been bolted to the manger after previously being stolen and recovered in 2004 and 2012.
Police said the thieves apparently also attempted to take a shepherd statue, but left it on the sidewalk.
Chipotle plans first price increase in 3 years
Justin Bieber crashes Drake Bell's album release party