James Tate, a student at Shelton High School, told Hearst Newspapers he taped the letters in a "safe and thoughtful way" late Friday and even wore a helmet while he climbed a ladder. But school officials apparently decided sneaking on campus in the middle of the night was out-of-bounds behavior.
Tate's message read: "Sonali Rodrigues, Will you go to prom with me? HMU Tate."
Tate and his two assistants were given one-day suspensions. Shelton High rules are that anyone suspended after April 1 is banned from the prom.
"I tried to appeal -- tried to just get a detention instead," he said. "I even offered to do community service -- like cleaning up the litter outside the school. Now I have a date for the prom, but can't go."
Rodrigues still plans to go to the prom. Her date is another girl whose boyfriend was also suspended for another incident.
Celebrity Breakups and divorces of 2014 [PHOTOS]