Collector Joe Yetman told The (St. John's) Telegram he paid $32 to send a registered and insured parcel from his home in Newfoundland to another collector in Ontario who had purchased the cards through eBay.
Yetman sent them Jan. 2 from a postal sub-station, insured for $1,100. He said after 10 days the buyer told him they hadn't arrived.
Canada Post spokeswoman Genevieve Latour told the newspaper postal inspectors determined the bar-code had been collected for shipment, but disappeared from the system after that.
"We've done everything we could. It's nowhere to be found," Latour said.
Yetman was paid his $1,100 insurance claim, she said.
Yetman's now offering a $2,500 reward, hoping knowledgeable collectors will spot someone selling the cards of Toronto Maple Leafs and Montreal Canadiens hockey greats, the newspaper said.
Beautician charged with giving client fatal silicone butt injection
Duggar sisters unveil Christian dating rules in new book