Men overconfident in their performance

Nov. 29, 2011 at 7:36 AM   |   Comments

NEW YORK, Nov. 29 (UPI) -- Discrimination against women may not be the only reason women hit a glass ceiling in corporations; men's overconfidence is also a factor, U.S. researchers say.

Professor Ernesto Reuben of Columbia University and colleagues asked MBA students to complete a set of math problems. Both men and women performed about the same, but one year later, the researchers brought back the same students, asking them to recall their previous year's performance.

The researchers found when they compared actual performance with recalled performance, most participants overestimated their performance.

The study, appearing in the Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization and Columbia Business School's Ideas at Work, found the major difference was men consistently rated their past performance about 30 percent higher than it really was while women consistently rated their past performance only about 15 percent higher.

In another experiment, the researchers found, on average, both men and women were willing to lie about their performance, but when participants had an incentive to lie, they lied more, and the incidence of lying increased as the monetary award for being chosen as leader increased.

Although women kept pace with men on how frequently they lied, women did not exaggerate their performance to the same degree. As a result, women were selected one-third less often than their abilities would otherwise indicate.

© 2011 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any reproduction, republication, redistribution and/or modification of any UPI content is expressly prohibited without UPI's prior written consent.
Recommended UPI Stories
Most Popular
Doctor to Jim Kelly: no evidence of cancer
New research explains insomnia prevalence among elderly
New data shows Melbourne is most well-rested city in the world
New research details rare cancer that killed Bob Marley
Daughters more likely than sons to care for elder parents
Trending News