Study finds breast cancer over-diagnosed

Published: July 10, 2009 at 12:17 PM

COPENHAGEN, Denmark, July 10 (UPI) -- One in three women shown to have breast cancer undergo unnecessary surgery and chemotherapy, scientists in Europe said.

Results from mammograms that screen for breast cancer lead to over-diagnosis and unnecessary treatment, scientists at the Nordic Cochrane Center in Copenhagen said in a story published Friday in the British Medical Journal.

Some breast cancers are inconsequential, but once they are detected women usually undergo traumatic and potentially harmful treatment, said Gilbert Welch, a professor of medicine who reviewed the study of over-diagnosis of breast cancer in Britain, Canada, Norway, Sweden and Australia.

Mammography is one of medicine's "close calls," a balance between benefit and harm, in which different people in the same situation might reasonably make different choices. Welch said.

"Mammography undoubtedly helps some women but hurts others," Welch said.

The Nordic Cochrane study examined breast cancer trends seven years before and after mammograms were introduced in the five countries, The Guardian reported Friday.

© 2009 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Order reprints



Additional News Stories
'Gone Wild' creator Francis gets probation (6 min)
Vale of York upsets BC Juvenile (12 min)
COL FB: Miami (Fla.) 52, Virginia 17 (15 min)
COL FB: Pittsburgh 37, Syracuse 10 (22 min)
COL FB: Texas 35, Central Florida 3 (33 min)
China opposes sale of 18th century relic (40 min)
Dancing in Silks Upsets BC Sprint (42 min)
fark
Miss England, who looks like a drag queen, steps down after nightclub brawl. Please welcome her...
17-year-old who thought the "pain and agony" he dealt with when running was normal, finds out he's...
Photoshop this bon voyage bid
Hasboro is having a diorama contest for their toys. Top 5 here. Much better than my use of toilet...
"Everything on eBay is fake or a rip-off" Yeah, tell that to the guy who picked up a lost Chaplin...
Christmas 1, Godless heathens 0