AMA docs still wary of pay-for-performance

Published: June 27, 2007 at 12:48 PM

CHICAGO, June 27 (UPI) -- American Medical Association delegates spent five hours hammering out a policy asking its leaders to battle flawed pay-for-performance schemes.

In trying to walk a fine line between being too shrill or too wimpy, dozens of delegates Tuesday delved into the mind-numbing sport of resolution editing, on-the-fly wordsmithing and entry into the Satanic depths of parliamentary procedure with flurries of first- and second-order amendments amid points of order, points of clarification and points of privilege.

For example, doctors debated, removed, added and eventually retained the word "active," which trustees interpreted to mean a proactive approach to solving inequitable projects.

The result of the all-day debate: "The message we got is that the House wants us to be more aggressive in making sure that pay-for-performance trials don't come at the expense of physicians or force physicians to compromise their basic principles," J. James Rohack, a cardiologist from Temple, Texas, and a member of the AMA Board of Trustees, told United Press International at the AMA's annual meeting in Chicago.

The delegates railed against all forms of pay-for-performance, whether worked out with government or suggested by insurance companies. William Hazel, an orthopedic surgeon from Herndon, Va., and also on the AMA board, said that treating two different patients -- an athlete and an elderly woman -- for knee surgery may look the same in hospital coding but may have very different resource usage.

"Yet the pay-for-performance trial may not be able to tell the difference," he told UPI.

--

Ed Susman, UPI Medical Correspondent

© 2007 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Order reprints



Additional News Stories
Any tan is a sign of skin damage (30 min)
Bruins sign Savard to 7-year extension (36 min)
Loneliness spreads; lonely get lonelier (39 min)
Women ski jumpers pushing Olympic bid (41 min)
Rays acquire catcher Shoppach from Indians (58 min)
Gordon leaves UCLA basketball team
Microsoft denies update problem
fark
Apparently, Charles Dickens left us with one, and only one, manuscript of "A Christmas Carol", and...
If you live in Maricopa County, you may want to get stocked up on popcorn. The Arizona cop ordered...
"Remember [when you used to work for] the Alamo"
Not news: Debt collector sues the wrong person. Not news: The debt doesn't even exist. Fark: The...
Baltimore Mayor Sheila Dixon convicted of stealing gift cards intended for the poor
Annual Fark demographics survey. Results will be posted next week. Help us figure out who that one...