The former couple dated and broke up in 2007, then reconciled last year. They recently split up for a second time.
"It didn't make sense for them to be together right now," an insider told the magazine, explaining Kelly is working on "Almost Human" in Canada, while Evans is preparing to direct the movie "1:30 Train" in New York City.
The source said the breakup was amicable and the Kelly and Evans "still care about each other."
Notable deaths of 2014 [PHOTOS]
Morena Baccarin to star on 'Gotham'