The segment, which also featured Patrick Dempsey, Taye Diggs, Ethan Hawke, John Krasinski, Ted Danson, Keith Urban, Josh Hartnett and Lenny Kravitz, aired after Sunday night's Oscars ceremony and local news broadcasts.
"On a night like tonight -- the night of the Academy Awards -- beauty is not only on display, it's analyzed, it's evaluated, experts are flown in to determine who wore it best, lists are made to determine who is hot and who is not hot and that's why I personally am happy to be part of an organization that supports beautiful people like myself," Kimmel said in introducing the clip "Jimmy Kimmel Live: After the Academy Awards."
The video then showed the various male members of the Handsome Men's Club voting on which other guy stars are handsome.
Kimmel, who described himself as the club's president, was ultimately ousted for not being good-looking enough after McConaughey staged a coup and turned the other club members against him.
2014: The Year in Music [PHOTOS]