Winklevoss was in a boat near Montauk when he spotted the fin of a shark in the water.
He posted the short video to Instagram Friday with the caption, "Shark Attack! Montauk."
Sharks aren't all that rare in these waters, in fact, a great white shark dubbed Mary Lee was spotted in the area in 2013.
Celebrity Families of 2014 [PHOTOS]
'Glee' star Matthew Morrison weds in Hawaii