'Sopranos' doc's actions raise eyebrows

Published: June 7, 2007 at 12:14 PM
Order reprints
NEW YORK, June 7 (UPI) -- When fictional shrink Dr. Jennifer Melfi dropped Tony Soprano once a colleague told others about the mobster, real therapists in the United States were angry.

"There were two issues in the last episode: the breach of confidentiality and the abandonment," said Dr. Dorothy Cantor, former president of the American Psychological Association and a practicing psychologist in Tony Soprano's "home state" of New Jersey. "They were both wrong."

"Confidentiality," Cantor told ABC News, "is the backbone of what therapists do."

Throughout the seven seasons of "The Sopranos," the mobster's relationship with Lorraine Bracco's Melfi was the one constant in his life. When she unexpectedly dropped him, James Gandolfini's Soprano accused her of being "immoral." Therapists who had praised the accuracy of the doctor-patient relationship agreed.

When therapists discuss patients with colleagues, they make a point "not to breach confidentiality. When talking or publishing, therapists make an effort not use names and to disguise the identities of their clients," Cantor told ABC.

As for her abrupt termination, "There is an old canard that an analyst should give a client one month for every year of therapy," said Bruce Hillowe, a psychologist and lawyer.

"The Sopranos" series finale on HBO is Sunday.


© 2007 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Blasts kill 7 U.S. troops in Afghanistan (<1 min)
Brussels studies derivatives reform (3 min)
Rare sheep may aid medical diagnostics (6 min)
Prado hits way to NL weekly award (12 min)
Jackson may get Forest Lawn burial (18 min)
Dead man may be linked to 5 killings (19 min)
Inaugural Swedish Open under way (20 min)
New University of Chicago policy allows men and women to share dorm rooms. Giggity 101
What happens when some loser posts a comment saying "we need to take the country back from these...
Marion Barry is going with the "biatch changed her mind about a weekend vacation" defense. Wait,...
"I got seven ****ing cows out, maybe going to the ***king highway And you need to let everybody...
Saudi Arabia acknowledges Israel's existence long enough to promise to ignore any Israeli jets on...
World's largest grease fire rages into its 14th hour. It's a bacon factory, everybody panic