U.S. judge rules in favor of MC5 film

April 7, 2007 at 2:36 PM

DETROIT, April 7 (UPI) -- A U.S. judge has ruled in favor of the creators of "MC5: A True Testimonial" in a legal battle between them and one of the band's original members.

The Motor City Five member, guitarist Wayne Kramer, had previously brought a suit against the documentary's creators, David Thomas and Laurel Legler, claiming they illegally using the band's music in their film, the Detroit News reported Saturday.

But now U.S. District Judge Andre J. Guilford has ruled in favor of the filmmakers, which gets them a step closer to finally releasing the documentary.

Guilford wrote, "Much of this case rests upon the credibility of witnesses, and the court finds that Thomas and Legler were far more credible than Kramer on key issues concerning alleged promises, representations and commitments."

The dispute between Kramer and Thomas and Legler started in 2003 when the documentarians refused to hire Kramer as music director. Then Kramer had music publisher Warner Chappell Music deny a music license to the filmmakers, the report said, which put a stop to the film's release since films have to have a music license to use copyrighted songs, the newspaper article stated.

Guilford has not made his final statement but is expected to do so within the next few weeks, the News reported.

Related UPI Stories
Topics: David Thomas
Latest Headlines
Trending Stories
Jennifer Lawrence pens essay on Hollywood sexism: I didn't want to seem 'difficult'
'Law & Order: SVU' will air Duggar-inspired episode
Chrissy Teigen is pregnant with her first child
Emilia Clarke named Esquire's Sexiest Woman Alive for 2015
9 politicians who've been asked to stop using an artist's song