The New York Post said producers of the Broadway musical are considering asking Lopez, who earlier gained fame on the TV series "Saved by the Bell" -- to join their production as accountant Leo Bloom.
If the Mel Brooks musical does convince the "Stars" runner-up to come aboard, he would be the second TV star to join "The Producers" this month -- joining as former "Who's the Boss" and "Taxi" star Tony Danza.
The potential hiring would also represent a Broadway trend toward using "Dancing with the Stars" as a veritable proving ground for potential stars.
"We watch the show like it was an audition," a Broadway source told the Post. "You can tell right away who'd be good on stage. And you can certainly tell if they can dance."
Kate Middleton recycles dress at movie premiere
Jordana Brewster on Paul Walker: 'He was an enormous presence in my life'