Bullock, 41, and Zeta Jones, 35, have been frequently mentioned in Hollywood scuttlebutt surrounding the not yet in progress project.
While out promoting her new film, "Sky High," Carter told reporters a "fresh face" needs to put on her famously worn superhero costume, MSNBC reported Monday.
"People have talked about Sandra Bullock but she's too old and so is Catherine Zeta-Jones. You want someone that is really fresh," Carter said.
She said she looks back at her old series and is amazed.
"Oh, my God, I think, she had a great body," she said of her younger days. "Where has that gone?"